Loyalty Program Trends 2024 report

Carlos Oliveira
Carlos Oliveira
Product Marketing Manager
Loyalty Program Trends blog post cover picture.
REPORT

Loyalty Program Trends 2024 report

From experience-based rewards to AI, the Loyalty Trends Report 2024 covers everything you need to know about what’s in stock for the industry. Learn key trends, goals, challenges and areas of investment that will disrupt 2024.

Since 2020, the Loyalty Trends Report delves into the dynamic world of loyalty marketing across diverse domains. 

Now, we continue exploring critical obstacles, unfolding trends, investment focal points, and the loyalty marketing aspirations outlined by our participants by offering an unfiltered insight into the trajectory of loyalty in 2024 and beyond. 

What will you learn from this report?

Our pool of respondents comprises 105 adept loyalty marketing professionals spanning the globe and representing myriad industries.

The 2024 report provides you with 40 easy-to-digest pages with answers to:

  • What challenges do loyalty marketers expect to face in 2024?
  • What loyalty marketing goals will be the focus over the following year?
  • What will be the most significant areas of investment in 2024?
  • What will the next 2-3 years look like for loyalty programs?
  • What trends will have the greatest impact in loyalty marketing over the next 2-3 years?
  • What brands are perceived as thought leaders in the loyalty space?

The report starts out by looking at the most common answers to the above questions, accompanied by a comparison between this year’s results and those obtained last year.

The second part shows commentary from loyalty experts, elaborating on their chosen goals, predictions and challenges for the future of the loyalty industry.

Additionally, we cover topics that were highlights in 2023 and are sure to keep disrupting the market:

  • Meaning of the AI in the loyalty programs
  • Loyalty as a key tool for upcoming recession
  • Loyalty as a strategic asset for a cookieless world

Read the full report to learn more.

Who are the loyalty experts behind the report?

As with earlier editions of the report, we conducted thorough interviews with the loyalty industry’s top experts. As a result, the report boasts responses from 105 loyalty marketing professionals working in-house, independently, and at agencies all over the world.

The shared industry experience of our respondents covers companies such as McDonald’s, eBay, Nike, Microsoft, Starbucks, HSBC, KFC, Virgin Atlantic, adidas, Visa, Mastercard, British Airways, Disney, P&G, BP, Shell, IKEA, Vodafone, Sephora, P&G, Tesco, L'Oréal, Harrods, Harvey Nichols, Lego, Marriott, and many more. 

What are the top-line findings for customer loyalty trends?

Compared with previous years, we see that AI, automation, and personalization have everyone’s attention, no matter the industry.

The Big Recession didn’t come in 2023, but it’s still looming, shaping how stakeholders and customers act. For companies, keeping current becomes a priority. And loyalty members are not only more budget-conscious – they are also more data-conscious and increasingly resist sharing personal information.

How will loyalty managers address these challenges? We hear three approaches over and over from different professionals

Challenges

Compared to the previous year, the top 3 trends stay the same. The ROI of loyalty marketing becomes more pressing and takes over customer acquisition in the fourth place. Combined, these signs indicate that the loyalty experts’ focus is on keeping and maximizing the value of current customers.

Beyond that, experts noted three other challenges in open-ended questions, starting from reducing marketing budget and optimizing customer acquisition costs.

Investments

In 2024, experts plan to focus their investments in:

  • Gamification / Game-based mechanics
  • Marketing automation
  • Experienced-based rewards

In the upcoming 2-3 years, experts consider these trends to have the biggest impact: 

  • Experience-based rewards
  • Gamification / Game-based mechanics
  • Predictive analytics
  • Predictive segmentation 

The full report includes context and commentary on each trend.

Loyalty program trends matrix 

The graph shows the importance of the chosen trends from two angles: the biggest impact on customer loyalty marketing over the next 2-3 years, and trends with the biggest urgency in terms of investment in 2024.

Loyalty Trends matrix reveals investment urgency and impact in 2024

What do the experts say?

Jaimi Farrey

Jaimi Farrey (LinkedIn)

Senior Loyalty & Personalisation Manager at Grill'd

What challenges do you see for loyalty marketing in 2024?

Budget cuts, the need for new technology to collect data and activate customer experiences, standing out from the competition.

How do you see the future of loyalty programs over the next 2-3 years?

Companies with loyalty programmes need to move with the times or get left behind. The ones listening to their customers, preparing for a digital-first generation, and evolving away from one-size-fits-all rewards and discounts will thrive and become actual profit centres for their business. The rest will fall behind.

Jason Whiting

Jason Whiting (LinkedIn)

Director of Membership at LEGO Group

What challenges do you see for loyalty marketing in 2024?

With cost pressures both on our customers and business, creating scalable value for members in a more competitive market will be a challenge.

How do you see the future of loyalty programs over the next 2-3 years?

Increasing gamification to provide salience and drive motivation to engage with the brand.

The full report includes 20 additional interviews.

The best loyalty programs

Some brands were mentioned multiple times by the experts. What they have in common is well-established loyalty programs that cater exactly to what their customers want and sometimes go far beyond the run-of-the-mill discount coupon.

Some initiatives, like Sephora’s Beauty Insider, Marriot Bonvoy and adidas’ AdiClub, use gamification and combine hard and soft rewards to provide members with a feeling of belonging and uniqueness.

Others, like Amazon Prime, My McDonald’s, Tesco Clubcard Plus, My Lidl Rewards, Nike Membership, Starbucks Rewards, and IKEA Family take a more traditional approach but manage to offer their loyal members convenience and special offers across hundreds of different stores.

Loyalty programs as a key tool for upcoming recession

Industry experts emphasize that loyalty programs are poised to become crucial for navigating market slowdowns and recessions, presenting an essential strategy for companies aiming for success.

The anticipated growth of these programs aligns with the increasing customer demand for savings.

Meaning of the AI in the loyalty programs

The meaning of the AI and practical use cases in the loyalty programs will be strongly related with predictive analytics and segmentation.

Its integration facilitates the creation of targeted segmentation and predictive models, enabling specialized offers and precise communication strategies. This AI-driven approach also plays a pivotal role in reducing customer churn while optimizing margins through enhanced data utilization.

The shift toward AI extends beyond segmentation, as explored in the full report.

Strategic asset for a cookieless world

As we find ourselves in a cookieless world with rising paid media costs, loyalty programs emerge as a pivotal survival tool.

Winning strategies hinge on adopting a data-driven approach to manage the digital ecosystem effectively, transcending traditional marketing methods. 

A crucial aspect will be fostering the growth of the customer base, which requires prioritizing customer insights, automated promotions, and communication. But, considering third-party cookies are increasingly unreliable, first-party data will be the cornerstone of success.

Join the community of 1000+ Loyalty Builders

Get a weekly dose of actionable tips on how to acquire, engage, and retain your customers

Starbucks logoDisney logoMcDonald's logoVodafone logoadidas logo
Tell us about your challenges and we will together
Join experienced 1000+ Loyalty Builders

Get a weekly dose of actionable tips on how to acquire, engage, and retain your customers.

adidas logo - blackMcDonald's logo - blackStarbucks logo - blackDisney logo - black
Join community

Table of contents

Success stories

See how Open Loyalty helps brands grow their business

limango

limango used gamification to drive user engagement and triple buying frequency
Banner - client Equiva

EQUIVA

EQUIVA doubled purchase frequency and saved EUR 68.000 with loyalty app-powered referrals

dacadoo

dacadoo’s digital health app boosted user activation by 62% with gamification