Let's shift gears and think about loyalty programs in a fresh, exciting way. Imagine if every time you shopped or used a service, you were part of a game-like experience.

With each purchase, you'd earn more than just points. You'd unlock new levels, earn badges, or complete fun quizzes. This is the essence of gamification in loyalty programs – transforming routine transactions into engaging, rewarding experiences.

Standing out is paramount, and gamification offers businesses a standout strategy to captivate customers. It's a smart blend of entertainment and engagement, turning everyday interactions into opportunities for customers to connect more deeply with brands. Companies are now embracing this innovative approach, integrating creative elements that resonate well with their audience, ensuring they keep coming back.

Join us as we delve into the top 10 examples of gamification in loyalty programs. We'll uncover how these brands are redefining customer commitment, making their programs rewarding and genuinely enjoyable. Get ready to be inspired by the ingenious ways businesses enhance customer relationships through this dynamic strategy.

Key takeaways

• According to Research and Markets, the use of game-like mechanics in non-gaming environments has exploded in recent years, and the gamification industry is now expected to reach $40 billion by 2024.
• According to our annual Loyalty Trends research, gamification encourages customers to invest a range of resources and is truly one of the most important investment areas in the coming years.
• Gamification is also gaining popularity in loyalty programs, as more and more brands are choosing to incorporate features such as levels, milestones, challenges, and badges into their loyalty programs to increase engagement.
• While loyalty programs can often include a configuration of different gamification tactics, most brands focus on 1-3 really well.
• Subscription-based loyalty programs tend to invest in gamification, using a wide range of game-like features with great success. Consequently, the higher the monetary investment, the greater the chance of widespread implementation of gamification.
• The simpler the rules, the easier it is for members to engage with the elements of gamification in loyalty programs.

What is the impact of gamification on customer loyalty?

What if transforming your shopping experience into a playful journey could be the key to building unwavering customer loyalty?

The impact of gamification on customer loyalty is significant and multifaceted, influencing various aspects of consumer behavior and engagement. Gamification leverages game-design elements in non-game contexts, enhancing experiences and fostering deeper brand connections. But how profound can this impact really be?

This innovative approach has proven particularly effective in the retail sector, where substantial benefits from gamified experiences have been experienced. By turning shopping into a more engaging and rewarding experience, gamification has the power to enhance customer retention rates, motivate purchases, and encourage ongoing engagement with the brand.

Reports indicate that the gamification market is expected to grow exponentially, with projections suggesting it'll reach USD 48.72 billion by 2029, demonstrating its increasing integration into business strategies. This growth is supported by the rising popularity of smartphones and the seamless integration of gamification with social networking, expanding its reach and effectiveness in engaging users.

For example, gamification strategies have significantly increased customer retention rates in the retail industry. When engaged with gamified elements, clients are more likely to return to the store, make repeat purchases, and become brand advocates.

Providing rewards, points, or badges encourages customers to stay connected with the brand, enhancing their loyalty and increasing the likelihood of repeat business. Retail gamification is rapidly becoming a trend, as it offers innovative ways to interact with clients, resulting in increased sales and stronger brand loyalty.

Furthermore, the North American market, known for its mature gamification techniques, illustrates the benefits of these approaches through increased customer engagement, loyalty, and substantial commercial benefits. Major companies have succeeded in utilizing gamification to enhance their market presence and client relationships, leading to increased sales and customer base expansion.

In summary, gamification profoundly impacts customer loyalty by making interactions more engaging, personalized, and rewarding. Its strategic application can transform the experience, foster sustained engagement, and significantly boost customer loyalty and retention, contributing to long-term business success.

What is a gamified loyalty program?

A gamified loyalty program constitutes an intricate marketing methodology that integrates sophisticated game design constituents within a conventional loyalty framework, engaging shoppers, augmenting their experiential journey, and fostering a profound allegiance towards a brand or corporation.

This specialized program leverages the nuanced principles of gamification, which is the strategic application of game-centric mechanics, aesthetics, and dynamics within non-gaming environments, aiming to transform the conventional loyalty accrual and milestone achievement process into an immersive, interactive, and captivating experience.

Below is a more detailed look at how it works and what it includes.

Points system

Loyalty program members earn points for their purchases or for engaging in specific activities the brand promotes. These points act like a currency that clients can use to redeem rewards, discounts, or exclusive offers, incentivizing continued engagement with the brand.

Levels and progression

Similar to levels in a game, customers can progress through different tiers or stages, often starting as beginners and moving up to elite status. Each level-up typically comes with its set of perks, motivating clients to aspire to the next tier.

Challenges and missions

Brands often set up fun and engaging tasks for users to complete, such as visiting certain locations, purchasing specific items, or sharing content on social media. Completing these missions can earn customers additional points, rewards, or recognition, adding a sense of adventure to the shopping experience.

Badges and achievements

These are visual symbols of accomplishments given to customers when they complete specific challenges, reach new levels, or hit particular milestones. They serve as a form of recognition and can be shared or displayed, often inciting a sense of pride and achievement.

Leaderboards

Some programs feature leaderboards that rank members according to their points, activity levels, or achievements. This adds a competitive edge, motivating customers to engage more frequently to climb up the ranks.

Personalization

The experience is often customized for individual customer preferences, behavior, and past interactions. This can make the program more engaging by ensuring the challenges, rewards, and experiences are relevant to each client.

Social interaction

Many gamified loyalty programs include social elements, allowing clients to connect with others, share their achievements, and even compete or collaborate in challenges. This can enhance the sense of community and belonging, further increasing customer engagement and loyalty.

Feedback and rewards

Immediate feedback, through points, notifications, or virtual rewards, keeps customers informed of their progress and achievements. This instant gratification can be highly motivating and encourage continued participation.

While it may seem like gamification gained traction overnight, it's been a trend at the top of loyalty marketers' minds for quite some time now. In the 2023 edition of our Loyalty Trends Report, gamification was voted one of the industry's most impactful trends for the second year running. Similarly, one-third of respondents said they intended to invest in loyalty program gamification in the coming year.

When done right, the use of game design elements in non-game environments has been shown to stimulate engagement and retention, decrease churn, and offer a more complex look at customers' preferences and motivations thanks to zero-party data, which "81% of clients are willing to share in exchange for a more personalized experience," according to a U.S. big data company, Formation.

Nevertheless, the basic idea behind a gamified loyalty program is to increase customer engagement and brand loyalty and encourage the target audience to buy more often or engage more deeply with the brand. By making the loyalty experience more entertaining and rewarding, businesses can foster a stronger emotional connection with their clientele, leading to increased satisfaction and long-term business success.

The most popular gamification-based loyalty mechanisms

As this trend develops, we see that different brands are approaching gamification in different ways, using different configurations of game design elements. Let's see what some of the most popular game mechanics include.

Point-based tiers & tier recalculation

This system rewards customers with points for engaging with the brand, which can be through purchases, social media engagement, or other interactions. As people accumulate points, they can move up through different tiers, unlocking more valuable rewards as they go. The tier recalculation feature ensures that members' tier statuses are updated regularly, maintaining engagement through a sense of progress and achievement. 

Spending-based tiers

Similar to point-based tiers but specifically focused on the amount of money spent, this mechanic rewards customers for their purchasing behavior, encouraging higher spending to achieve higher tiers with better rewards. Luxury brands often utilize this model to cater to their high-spending clients, offering exclusive perks and personalized services.

Challenges

Challenges engage clients by setting tasks or goals for them to complete within a specific timeframe. This can include purchasing certain items, visiting the store multiple times in a month, or sharing content on social media. Completing challenges can reward customers with points, badges, or unique rewards, making their shopping experience more engaging and fun.

Milestones

Milestones in gamification-based loyalty programs are significant achievements or goals members reach while interacting with a brand. The company predefines these milestones, which could be related to various activities such as the number of purchases, the amount spent, the duration of the membership, or engagement levels.

When a member reaches these milestones, they are often rewarded, which can help boost customer loyalty, encourage continued engagement, and enhance the overall experience. For example, a customer might receive a special discount or a free product once they make their 10th purchase, marking a milestone in their relationship with the brand.

Multiple milestones

Multiple milestones take the concept further by setting up a series of achievements for shoppers to reach over their journey with the brand. This approach helps keep people stay engaged over a more extended period, providing them with short-term goals to aim for and rewards to earn along the way. It's a way to gamify the customer experience, turning their interactions with the brand into a more rewarding and engaging journey.

Each milestone in the series is an opportunity to celebrate the customer's loyalty and to motivate them to continue their engagement with the brand. For instance, a client might get rewards after their 1st, 5th, 10th, and 20th purchase, with each milestone offering a progressively greater reward, encouraging sustained interaction and loyalty.

Referral milestones

This mechanic rewards clients for successfully referring new customers to the brand. It incentivizes existing customers with rewards like discounts or complimentary products and helps the brand grow its client base organically.

Spin-to-win/scratch-to-win

These instant-win mechanics add an element of chance to the loyalty program. Users can spin a digital wheel or scratch a card to win prizes, ranging from discounts to free products. This mechanic is engaging because it provides instant gratification and the thrill of winning.

Leaderboards/rankings

By showcasing customer rankings based on their points or achievements, leaderboards tap into the competitive spirit, incentivizing people to engage more with the brand to climb up the ranks. This can be particularly effective in community-driven brands where social recognition acts as a strong motivator.

Badges

Badges are awarded for various achievements, like completing a set of challenges, reaching milestones, or consistent engagement over time. They act as a visual representation of the customer's accomplishments and can be shared on social media, enhancing the sense of achievement and brand affiliation.

Quizzes

Quizzes can be an entertaining way to educate clients about the brand or products while rewarding them with points or discounts based on their performance. Sephora, for example, uses quizzes effectively to personalize recommendations, this way increasing customer involvement and sales.

Punchcards

A digital version of the traditional loyalty card, punchcards offer a reward after a certain number of purchases or actions. This simple mechanic encourages making repeat purchases and can easily integrate into mobile apps.

What are the benefits of a gamified loyalty program?

When delving into the benefits of gamified loyalty programs, it's essential to recognize how these innovative strategies revolutionize traditional loyalty frameworks.

By infusing elements of play, competition, and reward, they transform routine interactions into memorable experiences, fostering deeper emotional connections between clientele and brands. This strategic fusion captivates attention and cultivates a loyal community, driving engagement and encouraging continuous interaction with the brand.

Let's look at the nine multifaceted benefits these programs offer, from increasing consumer involvement to accelerating long-term business growth.

1. Enhanced customer engagement

Gamification introduces fun, competition, and rewards into the loyalty program, making interactions with the brand more engaging and enjoyable for clients. This increased engagement can lead to higher brand interaction and customer retention.

2. Increased loyalty and retention

By rewarding buyers for their interactions and purchases, gamified programs incentivize repeat business, helping to increase customer loyalty and reduce churn.

3. Improved customer experience

Gamification can transform mundane transactions into exciting experiences. This makes the shopping experience more enjoyable and can lead to positive word-of-mouth and social sharing.

4. Data collection and personalization

These programs encourage customers to share more information and engage more frequently with the brand, providing valuable data. This data can be used to personalize the customer experience, tailor marketing strategies, and improve product offerings.

5. Motivation through rewards and recognition

Gamification leverages principles of behavioral psychology, such as reward systems, to motivate customers to take desired actions. Leaderboards, badges, points, and levels can motivate clients to engage more and strive for higher status or rewards.

6. Enhanced brand differentiation

A well-designed gamified loyalty program can differentiate a brand from its competitors, offering unique value propositions that are hard to replicate and making the brand stand out in a crowded global gamification market.

7. Direct and indirect sales increase

Engaging people through gamification can lead to more frequent purchases and higher spending, directly boosting sales. Additionally, it can encourage the adoption of beneficial behaviors, like referring friends, which indirectly increases sales.

8. Social proof and community building

Encouraging customers to share their achievements and rewards on social media channels can generate social proof, attract new customers, and build a community of brand advocates. 

9. Cost-effectiveness

While there's an upfront cost in developing a gamified loyalty program, it can be more cost-effective in the long run compared to traditional advertising and promotional strategies, with potentially higher ROI due to increased customer lifetime value.

Incorporating loyalty program gamification be a powerful strategy to enhance customer commitment, increase loyalty, and drive business growth. However, the program's design should align with the brand’s values, resonate with the target audience, and provide genuinely valuable and enjoyable experiences to ensure its success.

Examples of gamified loyalty programs

From what we've seen so far, companies typically focus on configuring one to three of the above elements to engage their customers. Below, we'll look at these elements separately and analyze them in a broader context.

So, how do the best brand gamify loyalty programs? 

Point-based tiers by MSI

While tiers may seem like a pretty common loyalty tactic, they’re also an effective gamification tool that can increase sales and engagement. Tiers are also quite versatile in that they can be configured around points or spending. In this case, we'll focus on the former or points. 

A great example of a brand using point-based tiers as part of their rewards strategy is MSI, a world leader in gaming, content creation, and productivity solutions, with a global presence that spans over 120 countries. The company is widely known for their high-quality hardware, such as laptops, monitors, graphic cards, and lots more.

MSI has a loyalty program called the MSI Rewards Program. In this multi-tier and point-based scheme, customers earn points for completing different actions, such as downloading the loyalty app or referring friends and purchasing MSI products. Customers are also assigned to different point tiers depending on the number of points they have collected, and each tier comes with a unique set of perks for members to enjoy.

The program is divided into four tiers, which are:

• Bronze (0-199 points)
• Silver (200-999 points)
• Gold (1,000-1,999 points)
• Platinum (2,000+ points)

All tiers enjoy benefits such as birthday rewards and access to bonus points events, but the higher the tier, the more exciting the benefits. For example, silver, gold, and platinum members can unlock exclusive rewards and receive partner awards. Platinum members also get access to invite-only events.

The points can be redeemed on game vouchers, health and fitness memberships, and curated MSI wallpapers.

The use of tiers has been shown to be effective for a number of reasons. Most importantly, it gives customers a clear incentive to continue spending and engaging with the brand, leading to repeat purchases and more significant member activity. 

Furthermore, tiers also offer a sense of achievement (central to gamification) and exclusivity, as customers take pride in rising through the different ranks and reaping unique rewards. This reinforces the target behaviors and also leads to a potential increase in the frequency and value of customer purchases. 

In short, point-based tiers offer a relatively simple way for brands to enjoy many of the benefits offered by gamification tactics without investing in the more complex game-like mechanics.

Spending-based tiers by Farfetch

Though the two are focused on different metrics, spending-based tiers come with a similar host of benefits as point-based ones. Both reward customers for their engagement levels and encourage a higher purchase frequency, among other perks. 

An excellent example of a loyalty program based on spending tiers is Farfetch's Access Rewards. Farfetch is a leading luxury fashion platform for those unfamiliar with the brand. It's available to customers in over 190 countries and hosts upwards of 1,400 of the world's top fashion retailers, boutiques, and department stores.

Similarly to the luxury brands they collaborate with, Farfetch is highly committed to creating high-quality customer experiences that make customers feel appreciated. With that in mind, Farfetch launched its successful loyalty program, Access Rewards, to reward its top customers for their investment and encourage others to want to move up the tiers.

Access Rewards has five tiers (see image below): bronze, silver, gold, platinum, and private client.

Farfetch categorizes its customers into different tiers based on their spending, with each tier unlocking more rewards. 

Here's how it works:

1. Bronze Tier. This is the starting tier, which customers reach after making their first purchase.
2. Silver Tier. Customers advance to this tier once they spend €850.
3. Gold Tier. This level is attained after a customer spends €1700.
4. Platinum Tier. Reaching this tier requires a spend of €4000.
5. Private Client Tier. The highest tier, achieved after spending €10,000.

As customers move up the tiers, they enjoy increasing benefits such as free shipping, priority customer support, and personal styling services.

To ensure ongoing engagement, Farfetch reassesses the tier status of each customer every 12 months. This means customers must maintain their spending level to keep their tier status and the associated benefits. This policy encourages customers to continue shopping to avoid losing their earned privileges.

Farfetch's approach to implementing spending-based tiers for their loyalty program aligns well with their business model, as they primarily sell high-priced luxury items. This strategy simplifies the management and tracking process for the company since they only need to monitor the cumulative spending of each member. 

It's also straightforward for customers, who can easily understand how much more they need to spend to reach the next loyalty tier. This system naturally encourages customers to spend more, which is particularly effective for a luxury brand like Farfetch, where high spending is expected and encouraged.

Challenges by Kipling

Challenges are another powerful tactic used in gamified loyalty programs. From increasing engagement and participation to encouraging customers to act as brand advocates, depending on how they’re designed, challenges can be extremely valuable to a business.

For instance, consider Kipling, a worldwide brand known for its bags, luggage, and accessories, operating in 80 countries. They successfully integrate challenges into their loyalty programs, showcasing the potential benefits of this approach.

Kipling's loyalty program shares common features with others, offering welcome discounts and birthday gifts. However, the brand distinguishes itself by integrating gamification elements into its offerings.  

The introduction of "Kipling Friends" encourages customers to share their purchases on social media platforms, starting with Facebook and later expanding to include other platforms. This approach has proven successful, with clients earning 150 "smile points" for each social engagement. 

Members can redeem discounts for every 1000 points collected as these points accumulate. "Kipling Friends" exemplifies how companies can effectively utilize gamification tools within their existing framework to enhance loyalty programs. This strategy engages customers and transforms them into brand ambassadors, showcasing Kipling's innovative approach to building loyalty.

Milestones by Costa Coffee

Milestones are another practical gamification feature frequently used in loyalty programs and beyond. Milestones are reached by collecting a set number of points or making certain purchases. They're typically rewarded with a special perk, for example, a discount or a free item. How milestones are configured will depend on the program and the company that runs it.

An excellent example of milestones in loyalty programs comes from Costa, one of the largest coffeehouses in the world and a leader in coffee loyalty schemes. Costa initially disrupted the industry in 2010 with its points-based loyalty program, the first in the coffee industry. Since then, the company has won over six million loyal customers, while one-third of Costa’s sales are estimated to come from its loyal customers.

In 2021, Costa revamped its loyalty program, introducing a fresh approach to engage its expanding customer base. One key element of this revamp was the incorporation of milestones. For instance, Costa rewards its members with a complimentary beverage after they have completed eight purchases. Moreover, in alignment with their environmental efforts, customers using reusable cups receive the freebie after only four drink purchases. This strategic use of milestones contributes to Costa's continued success in fostering customer loyalty and engagement.

Thanks to Costa's use of milestones, its customers feel a sense of progress and accomplishment when making simple, everyday purchases. The rules are simple, which means members are always clear on what and how often they need to perform a specific action to earn their reward. Given that Costa Coffee Club enjoys almost unparalleled success, it's fair to say that the brand's approach to loyalty and gamification is paying off.

Multiple milestones by Delta SkyMiles

Multiple milestones, much like their singular counterparts, play a significant role in various gamified loyalty programs. In the context of loyalty rewards, a singular milestone is comparable to achieving a specific goal, while multiple milestones involve diverse objectives provided to the customer. Unlike Costa Coffee Club, where members pursue a single milestone, systems like Delta Air Lines' loyalty program, Delta SkyMiles, present participants with a range of distinct milestones.

For instance, Delta Air Lines, a prominent U.S. airline with a rich history and extensive global operations, exemplifies the concept of multiple milestones. Operating over 5,000 flights daily across 52 countries, Delta stands as one of the world's largest airlines in terms of passenger volume.

Members of the Delta SkyMiles loyalty program can accumulate miles through various activities. These include flying with Delta or its partner airlines, staying at affiliated hotels, renting cars from partner rental companies, and utilizing the Delta SkyMiles credit card. Including multiple milestones enhances the engagement and earning opportunities for program members, fostering a more dynamic and rewarding experience.

Delta's loyalty program incorporates a tiered milestone structure, allowing members to accrue bonus miles through various achievements. These achievements include traveling to specific destinations, reaching designated mileage or segment thresholds, or attaining a predetermined spending level on Delta credit cards. Milestone requirements vary across membership levels, including Silver, Gold, Platinum, and Medallion tiers.

For example, a member achieving the Platinum Medallion level by flying 75,000+ miles within a calendar year receives a bonus of 10,000 miles. Similarly, someone reaching the Diamond Medallion level by flying 125,000+ miles earns an additional 30,000 miles.

These earned miles can be redeemed for diverse rewards, such as flight upgrades, exclusive deals on accommodations and rentals with Delta's partners, and a range of other enticing options, including experience-based rewards.

Delta's milestone program aims to recognize and reward member loyalty appropriately and foster continued engagement by encouraging ongoing travel with the airline and its partners, this way enabling members to accumulate more miles and enjoy additional rewards.

Referral milestones by Harry’s

Referral milestones share the same logic as the milestones-based programs described above, except they focus on the number of referrals a member completes. To illustrate this mechanic, we'll look at Harry's, a DTC brand known for its shaving equipment and men's personal grooming products. 

Despite launching amid an already saturated market back in 2012 and having to compete with key players such as Gilette and Venues, Harry's quickly found its feet in the industry, thanks in part to their ability to respond to customer pain points and their ingenious referral program.

Harry's referral program features a straightforward milestones rewards system tied to the number of customers referred. The program utilizes a concise two-page microsite for user engagement. The first page collects email addresses, and upon submission, users are seamlessly redirected to the landing page (refer to the image above). Here, users can easily track their progress and access detailed information about the rewards corresponding to specific referral milestones.

Key components of the referral campaign configuration include:

1. Trigger: The first purchase made by the referee.

2. Rule for Referrer: Referrers unlock various rewards upon achieving specific referral milestones:

• 5 successful referrals result in a free shave cream.
• 10 successful referrals result in earning a free razor.
• 25 successful referrals lead to a complimentary shave set.
• 50 successful referrals entitle the referrer to free blades for an entire year.

Leaderboards/rankings by NikePlus 

Leaderboards and rankings are highly effective gamification features, particularly within loyalty programs. This strategy has proven successful in fostering a sense of healthy competition among members, ultimately boosting engagement and enhancing the perceived value of rewards.

Take Nike, a brand synonymous with athletic excellence, as an example. While the brand itself requires little introduction, Nike has ventured into the realm of subscription-based loyalty programs with Nike+. This innovative program incorporates leaderboards and challenges to incentivize users based on their activity levels. Members can accumulate points through product purchases and actively participate in the brand's social media community.

The accrued points within the Nike+ loyalty program can be redeemed for various rewards, including exclusive products, enticing discounts, and access to exclusive "experiences." This multifaceted approach enriches the user experience and leverages gamification to increase brand engagement. 

Most crucially, however, the program includes a leaderboard system, ranking users according to their activity levels and showing them how they compare to others. The leaderboards are well-designed and user friendly, and those who find themselves at the top also receive badges for their achievements. While Nike does their leaderboards well, the program makes uses of a whole assortment of gamification features such as challenges, milestones, and badges to appeal to its member base.

The data obtained about users throughout also allows Nike to offer personalized recommendations, relevant content, and early access to exciting new products to said users.

Badges by WW Challenges

As previously mentioned, badges stand out as a prominent gamification strategy embraced by both loyalty program participants and brands. Their effectiveness lies in their role as visual indicators of a member's progress and accomplishments within the program. Consequently, badges instill a sense of pride and achievement in users, reinforcing the desired behaviors and enhancing overall engagement.

Likewise, badges can be employed to distinguish members based on their program tiers or other relevant attributes.

A notable illustration of successful badge implementation is evident in WeightWatchers, a subscription-based weight loss and fitness program. This program incentivizes members to adopt healthy habits like food and activity tracking, weight recording, and participation in WW meetings. As members successfully meet these challenges, they accumulate "wins," which can be redeemed for rewards from program partners such as Kohl's or Headspace and experiential rewards.

Highlighted below are some examples of badges that members can attain.

To participate, program members must engage in various challenges available on the WW app, such as the Weekend Warrior challenge, where they track all three meals over the weekend. These challenges usually span a week, occasionally just a weekend, like the Weekend Warrior. Upon successfully finishing a challenge, members earn a badge on their profile and "wins," the in-app currency, allowing them to redeem various rewards.

WW loyalty program interface shows challenges, rewards, and a progress bar that fills as members earn more "win." (source)

The program features a tiered structure based on points achieved through wins:

• Tier 1 (1,500 wins)
• Tier 2 (3,000 wins)
• Tier 3 (4,000 wins)

This well-developed and comprehensive program offers various gamification features, including challenges, badges, milestones, tiers, and progress bars. What sets WW apart from other programs discussed in this article is its subscription-based model, enabling them to enhance the customer experience through a stylish, gamified app and experiential rewards.

The effectiveness of the app/program is evident, as it transforms every aspect of healthy living into enjoyable, manageable challenges that lead to both real-life and in-app victories.

Quizzes by Sephora

Quizzes are yet another gamification feature that works well in the context of loyalty programs. Their use offers tangible benefits to both the brand and the end-user. For the latter, quizzes are a fun way to earn extra rewards or learn more about various things. For the former, quizzes represent an opportunity to learn more about the customer and use the information to offer tailored experiences and market products/services that the customer may not have been aware of. 

An excellent example of a brand utilizing quizzes as part of their loyalty program is Sephora, a global retailer of personal care and beauty products, offering cosmetics from approximately 340 brands in addition to their private label. 

Sephora is also renowned for its loyalty program, the Beauty Insider Program, which has upwards of 17 million members in North America alone. Many different aspects make up the success of the brand’s Beauty Insider Program. 

Still, it could be argued that its beauty – pun not intended – really lies in Sephora's commitment to catering to individual experiences and personalizing the shopping experience. This can be seen in its use of various gamification tactics, particularly quizzes, which allow it to get to know its customers better and offer them products that suit their unique traits.

Sephora offers a wide range of quizzes for its loyalty program members. Examples of these quizzes include its makeup quiz, a skincare routine builder quiz, or its lipstick shade quiz, all of which ask members to answer a few questions about themselves, their beauty routines, and their physical traits to then provide them with insights about what products would suit them best. This is clearly a win-win, as customers benefit from some handy tips, which no doubt increases their loyalty. In contrast, Sephora benefits from engaged loyalty program members who can recommend extra products.

So we can see how well quizzes can work as part of a larger loyalty strategy, helping the brand market all of its products more effectively. Quiz results, in Sephora’s case, act as a trust marker, making customers more open to suggestions and more likely to spend more. All thanks to a quiz!

Punchcards by Caffè Nero

Punchcards are another effective gamification in loyalty programs. A simple and cost-effective way for businesses to track and encourage repeat business, punchards also create a sense of accomplishment for customers who keep returning for more.

A brand that has successfully integrated punchcards into its loyalty proposition is Caffè Nero, a UK-based coffee shop chain boasting 1000+ coffee shops in over ten countries. While it struggles to compete with the leading coffee shop players, Starbucks and Costa, Caffè Nero still rakes in significant profits – £135.7 million in the first half of 2022 in the UK alone, a 200% increase the same period the previous year.

Caffè Nero has made use of punchards for many, many years now, promising users a free cup of coffee after they've collected nine stamps. In 2017, however, the coffee shop chain followed suit with their competitors and took steps to revamp its loyalty program. 

Although their new loyalty program app has taken its loyalty game to the next level with a number of gamification-based campaigns, a loyalty payment app, and a wide selection of rewards, Caffè Nero didn't do away with its punchcards. Instead, it migrated them onto its app. Moreover, it responded to its consumers' desire for environmentally conscious products by rewarding those using reusable cups with an extra digital stamp.

Caffè Nero's punchcards have always been popular with its customers, and it's apparent that the brand appreciates this fact. Despite creating a brand-new loyalty engine, punchcards play an essential role in the coffeehouse's loyalty strategy. 

Summary

Now that we've gone through a lengthy list of different loyalty gamification features and how brands have taken advantage of them, you should know what successful gamification implementation looks like in loyalty programs.

Incorporating loyalty gamification elements can significantly boost customer engagement and retention. If we summarize all of the above examples, however, the conclusion is that simplicity is key.

Rather than overcomplicating their proposition and trying to pack countless gamification features into one program clumsily, the brands in the above examples have instead chosen to focus on a few and do them well. This approach aligns well with the principles of loyalty gamification, where the emphasis is on creating engaging, rewarding experiences that resonate with customers. Given the success we know they’re enjoying, this approach seems to have worked.

However, that isn’t to say that heavily gamified loyalty engines can’t work well. On the contrary, when significant resources are invested into doing so, the results can be astonishing. We’ve seen this in the examples of Nike and WeightWatchers, both subscription-based loyalty programs incorporating gamification strategies. They can afford to make the necessary investment. These brands also tend to offer experiential rewards and other rewards that may fall outside the scope of standard loyalty software for obvious reasons, showcasing the versatility and potential of gamification loyalty programs.

Learn about the best gamification software for your own loyalty program.

-

For more articles like this one, make sure to follow our LinkedIn channel and stay up to date on all our latest content.

To get some loyalty program inspiration, check out the Top 100 Loyalty Programs report, or peek into the future of the loyalty industry with our Loyalty Trends 2024 research.