

Nine in ten US consumers in EY's 2025 survey belong to at least one loyalty program, but the average member is active in only about five of the eight programs they join. Members who redeem spend more, and most loyalty teams now judge their program on retention and lifetime value rather than sign-ups.
Every statistic below names its publisher, year and who was asked, because an executive survey, a consumer survey and an analyst market estimate answer different questions. Figures older than 2024 sit in a separate, labeled section.
Most consumers are enrolled somewhere, but activity is far lower than membership, and US engagement has slipped since 2022.
The membership counts differ because each survey defines the base differently. EY recruited people who generally take part in loyalty programs, so its 92% is not a population rate. Deloitte surveyed members only. BCG counts every program a person belongs to, including dormant ones.
FigureDenominatorUse it forShare of consumers enrolledAll surveyed consumersCategory reachPrograms actively used per personPrograms a respondent belongs toCompetition for attentionActive-member rateEnrolled members of one programSizing your own business case
Only the last row belongs in a revenue model, and no survey supplies it. Compute it from your own data: members with at least one earn, purchase or redemption in a window that matches your purchase cycle, divided by deduplicated enrolled members.
Members spend more in every published comparison, but heavy buyers also join first, so the gap mixes program effect with self-selection.
The Numerator spend figures come from verified purchase data, which makes them stronger than stated intent. They still compare people who chose to join with people who did not. For a business case, compare matched members and non-members, or hold the program back from a random group.
Well-run programs lift revenue among members who redeem, but many programs do not pay back, and ROI proof is one of the most common problems loyalty teams name.
The McKinsey figures are from 2021, but they remain the most cited consultancy benchmarks on redemption and member spend. The redeemer gap is the practical takeaway: measure redeemers, not enrolled members, and treat low redemption as lost revenue, not a saving.
Loyalty teams define success through retention and lifetime value, track engagement most often, and want to improve engagement next. These figures come from Open Loyalty's own research.
SourceQuestion askedResultBenchmark 2027How do you define loyalty success?Retention and lifetime value 53.6%; revenue impact 51.8%Benchmark 2027Which success metrics do you track?Engagement 55.4%; financial impact 53.6%Benchmark 2027What do you want to improve next?Engagement and participation 41.1%; revenue and sales growth 25%Trends 2026What are your 2026 goals?CLV 59%; churn 44%; ROI 35%; purchase frequency 31%; acquiring customers 27%; revenue 26%
The two 53.6% figures answer different questions, and multi-select answers add up to more than 100%. By industry, hospitality, travel and airlines most often name financial impact, retention and engagement. Financial services and insurance is the only group with advocacy and referrals among its top metrics. Per-industry samples are small, so read those as directional. For how to define and calculate each metric, see our guide to loyalty program metrics.
Members still value savings they can use right away, even as more programs add experiences.
Both frustrations point to the same fix: rewards that feel reachable. If a member needs a year of purchases to reach the first reward, expect the low activity rates in the section above.
Paid tiers and memberships are now mainstream, especially among younger shoppers.
The Numerator spend figures above (Prime, Walmart+, Kroger Boost) are paid or subscription programs, which is part of why their member share of wallet is so much higher.
Younger members will trade data for relevance, but discomfort with data sharing is rising overall.
That is an expectation, not a measured lift. For study results and mechanic-level data, see our gamification statistics.
Integration, strategy and data top the list of challenges, and legacy platforms are the main reason companies replace their setup.
The 81.2% comes from conversations with companies already replacing a platform, so it is not the share of all programs that struggle.
Research firms define this market differently: some count software only, others add services and reward fulfillment. Their figures do not reconcile, so quote one firm, with its year and scope, and never average across firms. A market-size estimate measures vendor spend, not how many consumers are enrolled or active.
These numbers appear on most statistics pages. They come from older research, so label the year if you use them.
Some figures that circulate widely are left out on purpose. We could not trace "16.6 programs per consumer, 55% active" or "17.4 programs, 8.4 active" to a primary source we can cite, so use the Deloitte and BCG enrollment figures above instead.
Use executive surveys to choose which metrics to model, consumer surveys to set cautious behavior assumptions, and analyst estimates for market context only. None of them proves ROI for your own program.
Source typeCan supportCannot supportBusiness-case lineLoyalty professional surveys (Open Loyalty Benchmark 2027, Trends 2026, EY organization survey)What peers prioritize and which metrics a board expectsOutcomes: respondents report what they track, not what they achievedRetention and CLV as headline KPIsConsumer surveys (EY, Deloitte, BCG)Enrollment, stated attitudes, switching intentMeasured spend lift; stated intent runs ahead of behaviorFrequency and retention assumptions, entered as rangesPurchase data (Numerator)Observed member vs non-member spend at named retailersProgram effect, since members self-selectUpper bound for share-of-wallet assumptionsConsultancy benchmarks (McKinsey)Planning ranges for redemption and segmentationA forecast for your baseScenario bands for CLVAnalyst market estimatesCategory size and growth directionAdoption or program performanceBackground onlyYour own holdout dataIncremental frequency, CAC and CLVResults in other marketsEvery line that finance will sign off
We recommend building each line from the lowest row that has data. A holdout group, meaning eligible customers deliberately left out of the program or a new mechanic for a set period, is the only source on this list that measures your own uplift.
92% of US consumers surveyed by EY in 2025 were enrolled in at least one loyalty program. EY's panel was recruited from people who generally take part in loyalty programs, so the rate across all adults is likely lower. Deloitte's 2026 survey found members enroll in eight programs on average but are active in five.
The average US consumer belongs to more than 15 loyalty programs and the average European to nine, according to BCG's 2024 survey. Deloitte's 2026 survey of loyalty members found an average of eight enrolled and five actively used. The difference comes from what each survey counts as a membership.
Yes, in most measured cases. McKinsey found top-performing programs lift revenue from redeeming customers by 15% to 25% a year, and 56% of members in Deloitte's 2026 survey say they spend more because of a program. McKinsey also found around two-thirds of established programs fail to deliver value, so design and measurement decide the result.
Grand View Research estimates the global loyalty management market will reach USD 31.11 billion by 2033, growing 10.7% a year from 2026. Other firms publish different figures because they define the market differently, so quote one firm with its year and scope.
Engagement is the most tracked success metric (55.4%), followed by financial impact (53.6%), in Open Loyalty's Loyalty Program Benchmark Report 2027. Retention and lifetime value lead how teams define success (53.6%).
The Loyalty Program Benchmark Report 2027 breaks these figures down by industry and program stage and includes a seven-question self-assessment, and the Loyalty Program Trends 2026 report adds five years of historical survey data. To see how Open Loyalty's points, tiers, challenges and referrals map to the retention and engagement metrics above, book a demo.
Get a weekly dose of actionable tips on how to build and grow gamified successful loyalty programs!