Logo of European Union
New
Loyalty Program Benchmark Report 2027: Per-industry statistics, self-assessment, and more!
Get the report

Loyalty program benefits: What they return and how to measure

Learn about benefits of having a powerful loyalty engine and find out how it can change your business game. In this piece, we dive into eight key benefits of loyalty programs, as well as the reasons behind their popularity.
Loyalty program benefits header

A loyalty program pays back through five levers: retention, purchase frequency, basket size, first-party data and lower acquisition cost. Each lever has its own KPI and its own mechanic, and each carries a cost that most benefit lists leave out.

Members gain savings, access and recognition, but only the perks they redeem keep them active. Whether a program is worth running depends on incremental revenue after reward cost, platform cost and points liability, not on the gap between member and non-member spend.

Loyalty program benefits at a glance: KPI and mechanic

A loyalty program returns value through five measurable benefits: customer retention rate, repeat purchase rate, average order value (AOV), first-party data, and lower customer acquisition cost (CAC). Each responds to a different mechanic, and the mechanic that lifts one KPI often costs you on another.

Tracking each of these through the right loyalty program metrics shows which mechanic is driving results and which is eating into your margin.

We recommend starting with the one benefit your margin can fund, because Open Loyalty builds API-first, headless loyalty platforms that brands use to design earn rules, tiers, rewards and integrations around a single KPI.

A quick win today: split members from non-members in your CRM and compare 12-month spend and repeat purchase rate. Members self-select, so the gap overstates the effect and works only as an upper bound. Low-frequency categories gain less from frequency mechanics.

If you run a large, multi-market program, it also helps to see how enterprise loyalty software ties these mechanics back to customer lifetime value.

The benefits side by side:

Benefit KPI Driving mechanic Main cost
Retention Customer retention rate Points balance and tier status that carry over Tier thresholds set too high leave a dead zone of disengaged members
Purchase frequency Repeat purchase rate Challenges and time-limited bonus earn Discount-led earn rules lift frequency but erode margin
Basket size AOV Tiers with spend thresholds Points liability grows when redemption is slow
First-party data Share of customers with consented profiles Enrolment and preference capture Data goes stale if it is not synced to the CRM or CDP
Lower acquisition cost CAC Referral rewards Reward paid per referral, plus self-referral abuse

‍

The Maslow’s pyramid for businesses.

What are the benefits of a loyalty program for your business?

A loyalty program benefits a business by raising customer lifetime value (CLV) through retention, purchase frequency, and basket size, while lowering the cost of keeping each customer. To turn these gains into measurable results, build your rollout around a clear loyalty program success plan.

Loyalty expert Pawel Dziadkowiec says acquiring a customer costs about $500-1,000, while keeping one costs about $50-100. He also describes a business "Maslow's pyramid" in which a loyalty program has moved from an aspirational need to the base of the pyramid.

Because the gap between acquisition and retention costs is so wide, measuring loyalty program ROI is the clearest way to see whether a program's spend is justified.

KPMG's "Me, My Life, My Wallet" report found that convenience and product quality are no longer enough, because customers buy on values and integrity.

Anxiety about leaving a device at home was found among 36% of Chinese, 35% of US and 21% of UK consumers (KPMG Global Customer Insights, Me, My Life, My Wallet). Our reading is that a program built only on discounts competes on the thing buyers already take for granted.

Which lever to pull first depends on your purchase cycle and margin:

  • Short cycle, small basket: use challenges or stamp-style earn to lift purchase frequency.
  • Wide spend spread, margin on larger baskets: use a tiered loyalty program with thresholds set above current average spend to lift average order value.
  • High CAC, satisfied base: use referrals to lower acquisition cost.

Measure the result as member vs non-member spend against a holdout group. Members self-select, so a raw comparison overstates incrementality.

Coffee shop loyalty program benefits

A coffee shop points-based program pays off when the visits it adds earn more gross margin than the free drinks cost. A worked example with illustrative assumptions, not benchmarks, shows how thin that gap is.

Assume a $5.00 drink with $1.50 variable cost, so $3.50 gross margin. The reward is one free drink per 10 purchases, and a member visits eight times a month. Reward cost is 0.8 drinks × $1.50 = $1.20 a month.

Break-even is about 0.35 added visits, a repeat purchase rate lift of roughly 4 percent. Measure that lift against a holdout group, since members who would have visited anyway add cost and no margin.

Margin erodes in three places. Members redeem on $7 drinks while earning on $4 ones, double-points promotions pull the earn rate forward, and a lift of zero leaves the full $1.20 as pure cost. Gamified challenges that target off-peak hours add visits when marginal labor cost is lowest. Breakage lowers reward cost, but only as a bonus.

How does a loyalty program improve retention and lifetime value?

A loyalty program improves customer retention rate and customer lifetime value (CLV) when its mechanics, such as points, tiers, early access and exclusive perks, give members a reason to buy again, and you prove the lift against a holdout group. For benchmarks on how programs perform across industries, see these key loyalty programs statistics.

Retention carries the economics. Loyalty expert Pawel Dziadkowiec says it costs about $500-1000 to acquire a customer and about $50-100 to keep one. If those figures hold in your category, each retained member extends CLV at a fraction of the cost of replacing them. To see how these economics play out in practice, review real-world loyalty program results from brands that have measured the impact.

The usual first read is member vs non-member spend, and it overstates the effect. Customers who enrol are already your most frequent buyers, so the gap existed before the program did. That is self-selection bias.

A holdout design removes it:

  1. Set the baseline. Record 12 months of retention rate, purchase frequency, and margin per customer for the eligible base before launch.
  2. Randomise before enrolment. Assign eligible customers at random and withhold the invitation and perks from a holdout. An illustrative range is 5-10% of the base, sized to the power you need.
  3. Run one full repurchase cycle. A grocery cycle is weeks, a fashion cycle is months.
  4. Compare net lift. Subtract reward cost and points liability, adjusted for breakage, from the incremental margin.

Holdouts are hard on a live program because existing members cannot be withheld from. Withholding perks from active members also risks complaints, and shared households or stores leak the treatment into the control group.

We recommend three workarounds, in this order:

  • Hold out new-customer invitations.
  • Hold out a single mechanic, such as early access, for a random slice of members.
  • Run a store or region holdout, or compare against the pre-launch baseline with difference-in-differences.

Small customer bases rarely have the volume for a clean readout, and the pre-launch comparison then carries more of the weight.

‍

The Average Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) by industry.

How do loyalty programs increase purchase frequency and order value?

Gamified challenges lift purchase frequency and a tiered loyalty program lifts average order value, but each mechanic fails in a predictable way when tuned badly.

A challenge such as "three orders in 30 days earns bonus points" gives a member a reason to return before the window closes, which moves repeat purchase rate. Bonus points in a slow season, for example double points in January, pull demand into weeks that would otherwise be quiet.

The earn rule decides whether that frequency is profitable. When challenges pay out in discounts, members buy more often but each order carries less margin, and the program funds purchases that would have happened anyway. Reward with points redeemable on higher-margin ranges or with non-monetary perks, and judge each challenge on incremental margin against a holdout group, not on order count alone.

Tiers raise average order value only when the next threshold sits within reach of current behavior. Assume, purely for illustration, that the median member spends €200 a year and the first tier starts at €1,000.

Most members see no path upward, stop engaging, and form a dead zone in the base tier. Setting the first threshold modestly above the median spend gives most members a visible next step.

The failure modes side by side:

Mechanic KPI it serves Failure mode Early sign
Gamified challenges Purchase frequency Discount-led earn rules erode margin Redemption rate climbs while margin per order falls
Tier thresholds Average order value Thresholds set too high create disengaged members Most members sit far from the next tier with flat spend
Seasonal bonus points Off-peak frequency Members wait for the bonus and stop buying at the base earn rate Full-rate purchases dip before each promotion

Fix the target before launch, for example selling 1,000 products by December and growing annual sales 30%, so the holdout comparison has a number to be read against (Apptivo & Sell the Trend). Before launch, plot members by distance to the next tier to confirm the thresholds are reachable.

What first-party data does a loyalty program give you?

A loyalty program gives you first-party data tied to a known member ID: purchase history, declared preferences, and timestamped consent. Together they drive personalized offers without third-party cookies.

The three data types and what each feeds:

Data What it records Feeds
Purchase history Items, basket, recency, channel Offer targeting, average order value, repeat purchase rate
Declared preferences Favorite category, size, channel Offer relevance, churn-risk segments
Consent records Purpose, timestamp, channel, withdrawal Lawful messaging under GDPR

According to a PwC report, most customers would share personal information for a better experience. Most survey respondents identified at least one product they intended to purchase in nutrition, supplements, and personal care (PwC Voice of the Consumer 2026). Willingness depends on value returned, so members need to see their data change the offers they get.

Volume is where data quality gets tested. We saw this in practice with USSF (US Soccer Federation): 60M+ loyalty points issued.

Data that stays inside the loyalty engine fails in three ways:

  • Stale segments: the CRM promotes a product the member bought yesterday. Early sign: unsubscribes right after purchase.
  • Consent drift: an opt-out in the program never reaches the CDP, so emails continue. Early sign: suppression counts differ between systems.
  • Duplicate profiles: history splits across a card number and an email address. Early sign: more members in the CRM than in the engine.

Purchase events and consent changes sync to the CRM or CDP through the program's API, which is a developer task. Decide before launch which system owns consent.

Can a loyalty program lower customer acquisition cost?

A loyalty program lowers customer acquisition cost (CAC) through its referral program, and only when an advocate-acquired customer, reward included, costs less than a paid-channel customer.

The baseline is high. Customer acquisition cost reaches up to $2,790 in healthcare and healthtech, with B2B industries ranging from $239 to $2,790 across sectors in 2025 (The Starr Conspiracy, 2025). Loyalty expert Pawel Dziadkowiec puts acquiring a customer at about $500-1,000, against $50-100 to keep one.

We recommend running a referral program when all three conditions hold:

  1. Advocate reward, referred-friend incentive, and fraud and operations cost per converted referral add up to less than your paid CAC.
  2. A holdout group shows the referred customers would not have bought anyway, so you pay only for incremental acquisition.
  3. Referred cohorts match paid cohorts on repeat purchase rate and CLV at 6 and 12 months.

A worked example, using illustrative assumptions and not benchmarks: paid CAC is $600, the advocate reward is $30, the friend's welcome offer is $20, and operations cost $10. Fully loaded referral CAC is $60. If only a third of referred customers are incremental, effective CAC is $180, still well below paid.

Where paid CAC is already low, as in grocery or other thin-margin categories, the same rewards can exceed it. In those cases, put the budget into frequency mechanics such as challenges instead.

What are the benefits of loyalty programs for customers?

Customers get four main benefits from loyalty programs: money back through a cashback program, personalized offers, early access and exclusive perks, and recognition at higher tiers. Each one pays the business back through a different KPI, and each leaves a different usage signal you can read.

The perks side by side:

Member benefit Signal that members value it Business result
Cashback program (points or money back) Redemption rate, plus breakage on unspent balances Repeat purchase rate; points liability kept in check
Personalized offers Offer redemption rate against a holdout group Average order value and purchase frequency
Early access and exclusive perks Share of active members using access windows Frequency; richer first-party data from opted-in members
Tier status Share of members within reach of the next tier threshold Average order value and CLV

A perk counts as valued when members use it without being nudged. A cashback program with a healthy redemption rate and a stable active-member share shows that members see the reward as reachable, which supports repeat purchases and keeps points liability predictable.

Two caveats apply. A high redemption rate alone can mean you are giving away margin on purchases members would have made anyway, so compare against a holdout group before crediting the program.

Low redemption points the other way: the earn rate is too slow, or the perk is irrelevant to the segment. Challenges tied to frequency show the same split. Case in point, Limango: +41% average order value, 3x buying frequency.

The one integration point is the purchase feed. Your developers send transaction events to the loyalty engine, and every signal in the table derives from that stream.

‍

‍

The customer journey with loyalty program included.

Loyalty program advantages and disadvantages

Loyalty program advantages are higher purchase frequency, richer first-party data, and lower acquisition cost. The disadvantages are reward cost, points liability, and subsidized purchases that would have happened anyway.

Loyalty expert Pawel Dziadkowiec puts acquisition at about $500-1000 per customer against $50-100 to keep one. That gap is the margin a program's reward cost has to fit inside. How each program type spends it differs:

Program type Main advantage Main disadvantage Metric to watch
Points-based program Simple to explain, lifts frequency Points liability, rewards to would-be buyers Redemption rate, breakage
Tiered loyalty program Lifts AOV near tier thresholds Low-tier members disengage if thresholds are too high Share of members within reach of the next tier
Paid membership program Fee revenue, self-selected high-intent members Small base, value must visibly exceed the fee Renewal rate
Coalition loyalty program Shared acquisition, wider earn options Shared data and margin, less brand control New customers sourced via partners

Our recommendation is to revamp or end a program when any one of three conditions holds:

  1. Incremental margin after reward cost turns negative. Measure it against a holdout group, not against non-members, who differ by self-selection.
  2. Active share stalls. Enrollment keeps rising while the share of members buying in the last 12 months flattens.
  3. Rewards go to customers who would buy anyway. If holdout spend matches member spend, the program is a discount with extra steps.

Revamp when the fault sits in design: earn rate, tier thresholds, or reward relevance. End the program if two redesign cycles still show no incremental lift. Judge only after a full purchase cycle; for low-frequency categories, that can mean 12 months or more.

Customer loyalty program ROI: Are loyalty programs worth it?

A loyalty program is worth running when its incremental margin exceeds the combined cost of rewards, platform, and points liability. The formula is net return = incremental margin − (points issued × redemption rate + platform cost).

The input most teams get wrong is incremental margin. Raw member vs non-member spend overstates it, because your best customers join first. A holdout group of 10% of eligible customers, matched on prior spend, isolates the lift the program causes.

The worked example uses assumed inputs, not benchmarks:

Input (illustrative) Value
Active members 10,000
Annual spend per member €420 (holdout: €380)
Incremental spend per member €40
Gross margin 40%
Earn rate 3% of spend
Redemption rate 60%
Platform and operations cost €50,000 per year

Incremental margin is €160,000 (10,000 × €40 × 40%). Points issued are worth €126,000, and at 60% redemption the reward cost is €75,600. Net return is €34,400, about 27% on €125,600 of program cost.

Raise the earn rate to 5% and reward cost becomes €126,000, which turns the result into a €16,000 loss. The same happens if the 3% earn rate holds but redemption reaches 100%. The program lives or dies on the earn rate and redemption rate, not on the headline lift in average order value.

Slow redemption flatters the P&L while inflating points liability. Unredeemed balances sit on the books until they are spent or expire, so track outstanding liability monthly next to breakage, and test whether the lift persists before extrapolating it into customer lifetime value (CLV).

For smaller businesses, fixed cost sets the bar. At these inputs each member returns €8.44 after rewards (€16 margin less €7.56 reward cost), so €50,000 of platform cost needs roughly 5,900 members to break even. A lower-cost tool or a smaller earn rate moves that threshold, and a customer base below it is a reason to delay the program.

‍

‍

‍

Frequently asked questions about loyalty program benefits

What are the benefits of a loyalty program?

A loyalty program raises customer retention rate, purchase frequency, and average order value while lowering blended acquisition cost. It also gives you first-party data on what members buy and redeem. The gain is only real if measured against a holdout group, because members self-select.

What are customer loyalty program benefits?

Customer loyalty program benefits are the returns a brand gets from members: higher repeat purchase rate, larger baskets, lower CAC through referrals, and consented first-party data. Each mechanic maps to one KPI: challenges to frequency, referrals to CAC, and tiers to AOV. Net benefit depends on earn rate and tier threshold, which set reward cost per incremental order.

What are the benefits of loyalty cards to customers?

Loyalty cards give customers rewards on purchases they would make anyway, plus perks such as member pricing, early access, and birthday offers. Digital cards keep balances visible in an app or wallet, so members see progress. Value drops when points expire quickly or thresholds sit out of reach.

Are loyalty programs worth it for small business?

Loyalty programs are worth it for a small business when repeat purchase is already part of the model, such as cafes, salons, or specialty retail. A simple points or stamp scheme can cost little to run. Skip it where purchases are rare, like furniture, because few customers ever reach a reward.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of a loyalty program?

The main advantages are higher retention, larger baskets, and first-party data; the main disadvantages are reward cost, points liability, and discount dependence. Members who join for discounts may buy only on promotion, which erodes margin. Model breakage and redemption rate before launch, because unredeemed points stay a liability until they are redeemed or expire.

How do you measure loyalty program success?

Measure loyalty program success as incremental lift against a holdout group: compare customer retention rate, purchase frequency, and average order value for members and randomly excluded customers. Raw member vs non-member spend overstates impact because best customers join first. Track redemption rate and cost per incremental order too; high redemption with no lift means you are subsidizing existing behavior.

How do loyalty programs increase repeat purchases?

Loyalty programs increase repeat purchases by giving customers a reason to return before a reward expires or a tier resets. Challenges and streak bonuses pull the next order forward, and points balances add a cost to switching. Frequency gains fade if rewards sit too far away or earn rules are unclear.

See how Open Loyalty supports these benefits

Open Loyalty supports these benefits through an API-first, headless loyalty engine that adds points, tiers, referrals, and challenges to your existing CRM, CDP, and eCommerce stack. More than 100 enterprise clients across 60 countries run it.

A tiered loyalty program built on the engine ties tier thresholds to average order value, and each earn and redemption event writes first-party data back to your systems, so you can measure the lift against a holdout group. Open Loyalty helped Raqtan Group / EKUEP achieve a 72% points redemption rate.

‍

Logo of company Open Loyalty

API-first loyalty and gamification engine

Purple gradient banner promoting Open Loyalty product sheet with download button and woman checking phone.
Weekly tips to build & grow gamified loyalty programs
Join Loyalty Builders
About the authors
Weronika is a Content Manager with over four years of experience in loyalty and gamification. She has a deep passion for telling stories to educate and engage her audience. In her free time, she goes mountain hiking, practices yoga, and reads books related to guerrilla marketing, branding, and sociology.
Join the community
of 4,000 Loyalty Builders!

Get a weekly dose of actionable tips on how to build and grow gamified successful loyalty programs!

Disney logo - blackMcDonald's logo - black

Customer loyalty know-how

Leverage resources from Open Loyalty’s gamification and loyalty experts to start smooth and move in the right direction